Feedback Request: Trophy fish size and length requirements

Hey all! One of the cool features of FellowFishermen is the Achievements system, you can earn achievements for most of your activity on FellowFishermen.com. The system is automatic and works great, however we want to make some tweaks to the "Nice Fish" and "Trophy Fish" achievements. We need your help deciding the length and weight required to earn the "Nice Fish' and "Trophy Fish" achievements for several different species of fish. Please visit the discussion here, we would love to hear your opinion. Thanks!

One thing I'm noticing is that certain big catches aren't getting the "Trophy" achievements they deserve. There are 2 achievements for many popular fish types - the "Nice" fish achievement and the "Trophy" fish achievement. For example, if you catch a good sized carp you would get the "Nice Carp" achievement, and if you caught a gigantic carp you would get the "Trophy Carp" achievement. The idea behind this is that most people who fish a decent amount should be able to earn a "Nice Fish" achievement, but the "Trophy Fish" achievements should be a lot harder to get but not impossible. Please visit the forum discussion and let us know what you think.